Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri Murders – Maryjane Buri Mulder, 48, and her daughter Paula Mulder, 21, were brutally murdered in Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey, in September 2009. Investigation Discovery’s ‘Signs Of A Psychopath’ Season 1 Episode 6 titled, “I Wanted Her to Hear It“ chronicles their experience. The offender was promptly captured, but it took the police several hours to obtain a confession. If you want to discover more about the murderer and how he was captured, we’ve got you covered. Now, shall we commence?
First Aired: February 5th, 2023
A man finds his girlfriend and her mother murdered in their beds at night; he calls 911 for help, but police discover his urge to seek revenge.
How Did Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri Die?
Paula Mulder was born in Egg Harbor Township, Atlantic County, New Jersey, on February 9, 1988, to Maryjane Buri Mulder and Patrick Joseph Mulder. She attended Atlantic Cape Community College (ACCC) between 2006 and 2007, majoring in liberal arts, after graduating from high school in Egg Harbor Township. Paula enjoyed experimenting in the kitchen, with flowers, and with her clothing. Maryjane, Paula’s mother, earned a degree in education from Padua Academy and Delaware County Community College in her home state of Delaware.
Paula is the largest breeder of AKC Bichon Frises in South Jersey and a 25-year veteran of Caesars Hotel and Casino. She used her leisure time to buy groceries and prepare meals for her husband and two young girls. On September 30, 2009, Paula’s boyfriend was surprised to find blood all over their Scarborough Drive home.
In a condition of fear, the man requested an ambulance and immediate medical aid. At 3:12 a.m., emergency personnel arrived at the property and discovered Maryjane, 48, and her daughter, 21 years old, both dead in different bedrooms from gunshot wounds. Maryjane was shot in the side of the head, causing a “gaping open” wound, while Paula was shot in the head and neck, causing instantaneous death. The cops conducted no searches for bullet casings.
Who Killed Paula Mulder and Maryjane Buri and What was the Reason Behind?
Nicholas H. Nigro III, Paula’s boyfriend, allegedly returned home at 3:04 a.m. and called 911, yelling, “I just came home, and my girlfriend and her mother were injured!” According to the showrunners, Nicholas’s 911 call revealed that there was “blood everywhere in the house,” including “all over the wall” in Maryjane’s bedroom.
According to court documents, while waiting for the police in the front yard, he also claimed to have seen the light on the second story of the house flicker. When the Egg Harbor Township Police Department came, Nicholas was patted down, his phone was confiscated, and he was thrown into the back of a police cruiser for questioning. After setting up a perimeter and conducting a thorough check of the property, investigators determined that no one was in residence.
The police arrived at Nicholas’s residence at approximately 6:16 a.m., just after EMS personnel had taken the dead. The authorities concluded after hours of interrogation that Nicholas was not an exceptionally bright student and had dropped out of school before completing his schooling. He split his time between his parent’s home and the residence he shared with Paula and her mother, Maryjane.
Nicholas is observed in a police interrogation stating that he is unemployed and must perform odd jobs to make ends meet. According to Dr. Nameeta Sahni, a forensic psychologist, he displayed classic psychopath features, such as a parasitic personality. While being filmed, he emphasised to the camera that he had an incredible connection with his girlfriend and even got along with her mother.
A forensic neuropsychologist, Dr. Jonathan Deright, reported that Nicholas exhibited no signs of grief upon receiving the news. Another characteristic of psychopathy is emotional detachment, but Jonathan maintains he concealed his emotions rather than displaying them. Nicholas changed his account when police questioned him about what could have led to Paula’s mother and claimed he had no idea what his girlfriend was doing behind his back.
His present position contradicts his past assertions of a strong relationship. Nicholas suspected a local cocaine dealer he only knew as “Fresh” when authorities probed him for possible suspects. Nicholas asserts that the authorities had been monitoring Fresh for some time, and his sentencing was scheduled for the next week. According to the drug dealer’s narrative, he went insane and destroyed the neighbourhood because he was so terrified of going to prison.
Nicholas thought that Fresh may have murdered his girlfriend and her mother because he owed the dealer approximately $600. But the police refuted his story absolutely and charged him with murder. Nicholas lost his composure and began fabricating stories when he realised that the cops did not trust him. Nicholas later admitted to murdering Paula and Maryjane after police threatened to incriminate his family.
Where is Nicholas Nigro Doing Today?
Nicholas, according to Nameeta, attempted to exploit his confession as a favour to the authorities and to restore control by portraying it positively. The forensic psychologist freely confessed that his desire to keep his family out of it mirrored his affection for them. To let Paula “hear what happened to her mother,” Nicholas stated that he had previously slain Maryjane. In court testimony, Nicholas described Paula’s treatment of him as “playing him for a fool” and “like a tiny puppet on a string.”
After Nicholas’ confession, he was charged with two charges of first-degree murder and detained on $2 million cash bail. Additionally, he was charged with possessing a firearm, tampering with evidence, and obstruction of justice. In April 2011, he was found guilty on all counts and sentenced to 125 years in prison in May of the same year. According to reports, he received a sixty-year term for the murder of Maryjane Buri and a sixty-five-year sentence for the attempted murder of Paula.
Nicholas received a concurrent five-year sentence for resisting arrest. Before his trial, Nicholas modified his story about being guilty. He swore, “I would never surrender.” Paula and her mother were and are my top favourites in the world. According to prison records, the 38-year-old is currently incarcerated at New Jersey State Prison in Trenton. The date on which he is eligible for release from prison is December 28, 2115.
Also Read: Deputy Mason Moore Murder: Where Are Lloyd and Marshall Barrus Now?