Where is Nathan Leuthold Now? – In this article, we will delve into the details of “Dateline” Season 22 Episode 56, titled “Deadly Valentine,” which aired on NBC. This episode provides insight into a tragic incident that unfolded on Valentine’s Day, 2014, involving the unexpected death of Denise Leuthold, a mother of three, at her parents’ residence in Peoria, Illinois.
Initially, authorities suspected a burglary had gone awry. However, what followed shocked them even more – it was revealed that the murder weapon itself had been placed by none other than the victim, Denise Leuthold. A significant breakthrough emerged from her personal journal, containing concealed clues that pointed to Nathan Leuthold as the perpetrator.
The narrative takes an intriguing turn as we delve further into the circumstances surrounding this perplexing case. If you’re curious about uncovering its secrets, including insights into the perpetrator’s identity and their whereabouts, rest assured that we are here to provide comprehensive information. Are you ready to embark on this investigative journey together? Let’s begin!
The Murder Plot of Denise Leuthold
Denise L. Leuthold’s life journey began on February 3, 1974, in Dade County, Florida. Her parents, Douglas P. Newton and Diane E. (nee Sailors), welcomed her into the world with open arms. She resided in Mapleton and attended Faith Baptist Christian School before successfully graduating in 1992, marking both academic achievement and a new chapter in her life.
On July 15th, 1995, Denise committed lifelong when she exchanged vows with Nathan Andrew Leuthold in La Salle, Illinois. Nathan recalls a fondness that began during their school years but was hindered by religious restrictions within their families.
Fondly remembering their early connection, Nathan stated, “Even in third grade when Denise was only in fourth, she was the cutest girl in school to me – even without knowing I existed!” Her wavy locks and carefree nature caught his attention. Over time, their friendship deepened, culminating in their wedding on July 4, 1995. This marked the beginning of their shared journey as parents, raising three children – Seth, Julia, and Jenelle – while also engaging in missionary work abroad.
Tragedy struck Denise Leuthold’s family in February 2013 at her parents’ home on 700 West Mossville Road in Peoria, Illinois. Upon returning home that day, Nathan discovered an intrusion and immediately called 911. First responders found an unconscious 39-year-old man with a fatal gunshot wound to the head. The presence of a .40 caliber handgun added to the gravity of the situation.
Denise and Nathan’s lives took an irreversible turn as we explored their journey and the events of that fateful Valentine’s Day.
Investigation and Arrest
On Valentine’s Day 2014, Nathan Leuthold and Jenelle returned home to an alarming scene: the garage door was open, glass was scattered around an exterior door, and Denise was missing. Nathan acted swiftly, escorting Jenelle to a neighbor’s house, where she called 911—signs of forced entry led law enforcement to suspect a failed burglary attempt.
Denise’s belongings were missing, including two firearms – notably a .40 caliber handgun later uncovered by Detective Shawn Curry. Her attire also provided crucial clues; her coat and gloves remained on, indicating that the fatal gunshot occurred immediately upon entry, ruling out an external break-in. As investigators pieced together the puzzle, it became evident that the intruders had sought spare keys before abandoning a vehicle at a park. Clues eventually surfaced in a garbage can.
Further investigation of the crime scene revealed anomalies. Glass fragments were near the compromised door, and drawers and cabinets were scattered across the kitchen floor in an oddly organized manner. Valuables like a television and video cassette recorder were untouched during the possible theft attempt.
Diane offered her perspective, drawing from her experience with high-definition televisions. She noted that while smaller items may have been taken, more valuable rings were specifically targeted. This raised questions about the motivations and knowledge of the potential intruders.
Nathan Leuthold was questioned due to suspicions of inside involvement. His alibi involved driving Jenelle to her 12:15 kindergarten class, which was carefully scrutinized. Michelle Lunquist’s testimony revealed that Nathan collected Jenelle around 3:00 PM after leaving school grounds at approximately 12:20 PM.
Law enforcement issued search warrants for the Leutholds’ bedroom, leading to a significant discovery. A day planner contained mysterious notes and passages from the Bible, providing key clues that would unlock a crucial piece of the puzzle.
The hidden message conveyed feelings of resentment and betrayal, suggesting a strained relationship. This message alluded directly to an individual named Aina Dobilaite, who played a pivotal role in uncovering the truth. Aina Dobilaite’s involvement became instrumental in unraveling the depth of this mystery.
Investigation revealed the intricate dynamics of Nathan and Aina Leuthold’s marriage and their connection to Aina Dobilaite. Contrary to assumptions, Aina was not a “20-year-old lover” but a key figure in their lives since their missionary work in Lithuania. Nathan sponsored Aina when she relocated to Florida on a student visa, providing financial support for education and living expenses.
Details emerged suggesting that Nathan and Aina frequented a local spa, raising questions about the nature of their relationship. Tensions escalated when Aina faced expulsion due to Nathan’s inappropriate behavior, casting doubt on their connection. Subsequent investigations led to Nathan’s arrest for first-degree murder charges.
Denise Leuthold’s untimely demise unraveled as a complex web of relationships, motives, and connections. This complexity posed challenges for investigators as they pieced together the case. Denise, Nathan, and Aina played central roles in this intricate narrative.
Prosecution of Nathan Leuthold
Nathan Leuthold was swiftly found guilty of first-degree murder by a jury after six days of meticulous analysis involving recovered emails, site histories, and 40 witnesses testifying against him. Despite attempts to challenge the accusations, all appeals were dismissed.
Throughout legal proceedings, both Nathan and Aina vehemently denied an extramarital affair and maintained their innocence. However, the legal system ultimately determined Nathan’s guilt, resulting in a first-degree murder conviction and an 80-year prison sentence at Menard Correctional Center. He will likely remain incarcerated until 2093, when he becomes eligible for release.
“Dateline: Unforgettable” chronicles Nathan Leuthold’s trial and sentencing, becoming a part of legal history. The show explores his chilling crimes within the Illinois Department of Corrections prison, reflecting on the complexity of justice and its enduring impacts.
Also Read: Dateline 17×11 Justice For Sparkle: Sparkle Rai Murder
