Joan Bent Murder Case: A strange event happened in Watervliet, New York, on a cold February evening in 1986. The people who lived there would be troubled by the event for years to come. There is no sign of Joan Carol Donlon Peterson Bent, who was a loving mother, a devoted wife, and a respected housekeeper. At first, her disappearance seemed like a sad but common case of a person going missing. But just a few days later, her horrifyingly dead body was found hidden in the trunk of her own car. This turned the search into a full-on murder investigation.
THE MYSTERIOUS VANISHING OF JOAN BENT
Joan Bent, born in 1938 in Cohoes, New York, was known for her kindness and commitment to her family. After a failed first marriage to Dennis B. W. Peterson, Jr., with whom she had two daughters, she later found companionship with Donald Bent. Married in 1982, they shared a home in Watervliet and seemed like a happy couple from the outside.
But everything changed on February 16, 1986. Joan dropped off a co-worker in the late afternoon and was expected to return home for a pot roast dinner Donald had prepared. According to Donald, she came home, they had dinner, and she later left again around 6:30 p.m. to return to work. He claimed it was the last time he saw her.
As hours passed and Joan didn’t come back, concern turned to panic. Donald began calling friends and family before filing a missing person report the next day. Joan’s car was also missing. The community was rattled, and authorities began a widespread search.
THE TRAGIC DISCOVERY
Nearly a week later, on February 22, 1986, a local motel worker noticed a car that had been sitting in the lot for days. Inside the trunk, police discovered the frozen body of Joan Bent. Her purse and a cryptic note were also found in the car. It was a devastating moment that turned the missing person case into a murder investigation.
The autopsy revealed disturbing details: Joan had been strangled by ligature, and the contents of her stomach included pot roast—but no sign of cookies, which Donald had claimed she baked after dinner. This timeline discrepancy would become a vital clue.
FORENSIC CLUES AND CRUMBLING LIES
Police launched a thorough investigation and began re-interviewing those close to Joan. Neighbors stated they saw Joan’s car parked at home around 5:30 p.m.—after she supposedly returned from dropping off her co-worker. But it was gone again by 9:30 p.m., conflicting with Donald’s version of events.
A decoded note found in Joan’s car pointed to a possible affair. Co-workers mentioned that Joan had a “special friend” named Ed Zimmer. She had not returned to work that evening as Donald claimed. Investigators looked into other suspects, including a former employee she had recently fired and a contractor who had allegedly pursued her romantically.
However, all suspects were cleared—except one: her husband, Donald Bent.
A DARK MOTIVE EMERGES
More troubling details came to light. Joan had reportedly found out about an affair Donald was having with one of their tenants, Anner Jones, whom she later evicted. She had even met with a lawyer to discuss divorce just days before her death. Financial stress was also mounting in their household, with Donald allegedly suggesting home renovations to make extra income.
When questioned, Donald passed three polygraph tests. Still, the autopsy—conducted weeks later—became the turning point. It proved that Joan died shortly after eating dinner, not after leaving for work, indicating she was killed at home. Prosecutors believed she was murdered because she threatened to divorce Donald, which would leave him homeless and without financial support.
TRIAL AND CONVICTION
Donald Bent was arrested in April 1987 and charged with second-degree murder. His trial began in June 1988. Prosecutors argued that he killed Joan in a premeditated act driven by money and betrayal. Donald continued to deny involvement, accusing the system of being against him and even saying he had been “sodomized by the system.”
His defense team claimed the media coverage had swayed the jury. But the forensic evidence and Joan’s recent actions painted a compelling picture of motive and opportunity. On June 3, 1988, the jury found him guilty of second-degree murder. Donald was sentenced to 25 years to life.
WHAT HAPPENED TO DONALD BENT?
Donald became eligible for parole in 2012, but his requests were denied several times. He maintained his innocence for years. However, a crucial piece of information came from his daughter, Dawn Bent. In a moment of reflection, she asked her father if he had killed Joan. He responded, “Yes, I did.”
After serving 30 years behind bars, Donald Bent was finally released on parole on August 2, 2018. His freedom was short-lived. Less than two years later, on January 8, 2020, he passed away. The cause of death was not publicly disclosed.
THE LEGACY OF A TRAGIC CASE
The murder of Joan Bent continues to be a haunting reminder of how deception and desperation can destroy lives. Her story, and the investigation that followed, has been featured in several true crime documentaries, keeping the memory of her life and tragic death alive. While justice was eventually served, the pain left behind for her daughters, Laurie and Deborah, and her community, remains everlasting.
For more true crime stories, updates, and in-depth TV coverage, be sure to visit tvacute.com regularly — your source for gripping real-life mysteries and dramatic storytelling.
Lisa Stasi Murder: Where Is John Robinson?
